The term “underrated” is one of the most overrated phrases in the sports lexicon.
Nobody really knows what it means, although it apparently has something to do with a player not receiving as much attention as he deserves. On the other hand, when enough people say a guy is “underrated,” he inevitably becomes overrated for being underrated.
Not that we’ll let that stop us. Looking at production and using All-Star berths — or lack thereof — as a barometer, here is a lineup of the most underrated players in baseball. Whatever that means.
C — Ramon Hernandez, Reds
Now with his fourth team and in his 13th season, Hernandez always has been a solid hitter, especially for a catcher. He’s the perfect definition of underrated — the kind of guy who could be picked up at little expense and will quietly put together a productive season.
He made his only All-Star team in 2003.
1B — Kevin Youkilis, Red Sox
OK, we’re cheating here. It’s silly to call somebody underrated when he has made two All-Star teams, including one as a starter, and twice has finished in the top six in MVP voting. But Youkilis’ skills are the type that don’t receive enough attention.