Be honest. You didn’t expect the teachers union to capitulate and just accept charter schools even when such schools were mandated by voters, did you? Of course not. The Washington Education Association notified members in a recent letter that it will mount a legal challenge to Initiative 1240, which passed in November and authorized eight charter schools per year over five years in Washington. Forty schools over five years is no sea change, but it’s the slippery slope that worries the WEA.We don’t blame the union. Blocking reform proposed by nonunion forces is basic to its mission. But here’s the simple reality that makes union leaders squirm: If charter schools fail, they are closed. If charter schools succeed, the result is better education. How could an organization with “Education” as its middle name possibly oppose better schools?
The answer is simple, though unconfessed by union leaders: It’s their way or the highway.
Not according to voters, 50.6 percent of whom statewide (52.3 percent in Clark County) passed Initiative 1240. It must annoy the WEA hierarchy that I-1240 — unlike many issues — drew steady support on both sides of the Cascades, passing in 11 western counties and seven on the east side.
However the legal fight goes, don’t expect any breathtaking changes in our state. It took four ballot measures to get to this point. And a story this week at washingtonstatewire.com quotes charter school pioneer James Spady, who filed the first charter school initiative back in 1995: “(Initiative 1240) was seriously vetted for constitutional issues. There is case law which says that the Legislature has broad authority to implement a public school system. When the people pass a law by initiative, they are exercising their constitutional legislative power.”