| Good times in the wake of Sunday's column about horse racing (click here for column). Here's a sampling of the response:
From an e-mailer in Marana, Ariz.: I agree with your questioning of why people who love the sport continue loving it after witnessing a horrible event such as Saturday's? I cannot understand.
From e-mail: We couldn't agree more with your article, and we HAVE quit watching the "big 3" of horse racing. It hasn't done any good, nor will it. There is too much money riding on these animals to allow for compassion or concern for the well-being of the creatures!
From e-mail: While tragedy has struck recently in horse racing, many races don't end with the demise of a horse. These horses love to run and would hate it if they couldn't. Belle died doing what she loved and went out in a blaze of glory. Horse racing isn't the only sport where animals and/or humans die. Remember the 2001 Daytona 500 where the modern day hero Dale Earnhardt died? People die or get injured all the time in cars, even if it isn't televised. Does that mean we should stop watching NASCAR or any other car races?
From e-mail: I completely disagree with your article. Should we stop driving cars because people die in accidents? Stop flying in aircraft because they crash sometimes? I have to assume that you do not follow horse racing on a regular basis to write such a knee jerk article. There are hundres, thousands of horses that run 40 to 80 times and have no problem. You probably watch racing a few times a year and from this you say because of a few injuries you want it stopped. Any time a horse dies its horrible, and gives me a sick feeling. It just so happens its happened a few times lately on the big stage.
(Greg writes: Hmmm, and here I thought I wrote that horse racing shouldn't be stopped. But thanks for reading.)
From e-mail: The strongest word I can respond to your column with is "AMEN!" ... it's time to have more respect for God's creatures and find our "entertainment" somewhere else.
From e-mail: ... praise for having the courage to write an article about the tragic toll of horse racing that needed to be told ... I appreciate your paper standing up for what is right and just.
From e-mail: Thank you for writing this article. As a horsewoman for sixteen years, and having worked in the equine pharmaceutical industry, there is much cruelty to horses in many equine pursuits, all in the name of sport. In order to compete in those prestigious horse races, juvenile horses -- the equivalent of children -- must start racing. ... A number of horses AND riders have died recently, though nothing much has changed since the very public string of deaths during the Olympics in Spain. You are right -- the only way to stop this cruelty, as with every other cruel thing we do for sport, or luxury, or prurient satisfaction, is not create a market for it. The responsibility lies with the consumer.
From the online comments: As a former "groom" of the harness race horse "industry", I do remember similar, unfortunate events that the horses sustain in the name of human prestige and "accomplishment".
From the online comments: I am a horse loving person. Raised with horses, wanted to be a jockey when I was a kid. Now, I after this event, I solidify my growing belief that horse racing as an industry, as a sport should stop. ... It needs to end. I feel the same for bull fighting and even rodeo. It is inhumane, it is cruel -- sports only for human entertainment. I cant stand it.
From online: Imagine if it were a little girl who just ran. How cruel we would think it was. Oh no! We forced her to run and then she broke her ankles, let's put her down. Makes me sick sick sick.
From online: This has been called "the sport of kings", but it has become the sport of the mindless ... like the romans who gathered to watch the gladiators.
From online: What a ridiculous piece of nonsense you have just written. The Kentucky Derby has been run for 134 years and according to reports I've read, this is the first catastrophic breakdown. Where's your outrage over the thousand of cats and dogs that are hit by cars every year? Perhaps we should ban pet ownership. Or better yet, outlaw cars. ... Stop being a weenie.
(Greg writes: Hmmm, and here I thought I wrote that horse racing shouldn't be banned. But thanks for reading.)
From voice mail: I just want to thank you for writing such a wonderful article. I am very, very concerned at what's happening at the race track.
From voice mail: Sad, sad thing that happened. However, by watching we make it better. Auto racing, football, any sport; by watching we make it better. ... Do we stop NASCAR, the drag races? What about putting together a paper? There's danger in that.
And finally, my favorite voice mail of the week, brought to you in it's entirety: It's just kind of irresponsible sports writing for somebody that evidently has no clue as to what horse racing and breeding and raising these horses and all the triple effect, domino effect of these industries and all the thousands and thousands of people involved. You could care less about the effect that your article does to somebody like that. Maybe we ought to start putting articles in there about the kind of writer that you are. You're a f*&$ing idiot. |