When this recipe was first created by The Silver Palate catering and take out shop on the Upper East Side of Manhattan, it earned an immediate following. When the recipe was later published in “The Silver Palate Cookbook” by Sheila Lukins and Julee Rosso, it was a revelation, mostly thanks to its eccentric ingredient list: Vinegar? Olives? Prunes? Capers? Garlic? Brown sugar? White wine? All in one dish?
Yes! To taste it was to be converted.
And so for a nice chunk of time during the ’80s, this dish made appearances on tables all over the country, for family dinners or for entertaining. I grew up on this dish (my mother was an early adopter of it). It was one of the first “grown up” meals I served to family and friends as a budding cook, and not too long ago I even made it to bring to a kindergarten potluck for one of my kids.
Of course, I also had a deeper connection to this recipe. My father, Peter Workman, published the “Silver Palate Cookbook,” so I really felt like the recipe was part of my family’s culinary history.
And for a long time it was the first dish on my Passover menu every year. Thankfully, this is not a dish to forget, or imagine to be dated in any way. The faultless and brilliant combination of flavors is timeless, the recipe is pretty foolproof, the chicken is unfailingly moist, and it can be made ahead. Make it again, if you have forgotten it for a while. Or make it for the first time, and just try to tell me that you’re not a card-carrying lifetime chicken marbella fan.