Sunday, August 7, 2022
Aug. 7, 2022

Linkedin Pinterest

Evergreen teachers picket amid contract talks

Pressure mounts with vote to ratify one day before first day of school

By , Columbian Education Reporter

About 100 Evergreen Public Schools teachers gathered at two busy intersections along Southeast Mill Plain Boulevard on Friday morning, holding picket signs and waving at passing drivers. Several drivers honked in support.

With less than two weeks before school begins Aug. 31, the district’s 1,830 teachers do not have a new contract. Evergreen Education Association representatives and district officials have been meeting since March to hammer out a new contract. But time is running out.

Thursday was the first time a state-appointed mediator joined the bargaining sessions. Four more mediated bargaining sessions are planned for next week. At the union’s general membership meeting Aug. 30, members will either vote to ratify a new contract or vote to strike.

“There hasn’t been any significant movement,” said Rob Lutz, union president. “The district continues to nibble around the edges. They have a desire to hoard money so they can put a computer in front of every student. They are prioritizing computers over professionals. It’s really disappointing.”

On Friday, picketing teachers shared their personal grievances.

Chris Kinder, a math teacher at Pacific Middle School, spoke about how the shortage of substitute teachers affects students as well as other teachers. 

“Sometimes, when teachers are out sick, the principal steps in to cover a class,” she said.

Robert Cozzi, 28, is beginning his second year of teaching math at Wy’east Middle School. Previously, he was a manager at Starbucks and trained employees. He realized he enjoyed teaching. He recalled being inspired by his history teacher at Mountain View High School and decided to go back to school to become a teacher. But money is tight. Cozzi worked a summer job “so my wife and I could survive,” he said.

Bob Kenck, a math teacher at Frontier Middle School, has been teaching for 35 years, and has been teaching in Evergreen for 25 years. As more and more special needs students are placed in basic education classrooms, he says the kids and the teachers need more support. In one of his classes of 26 students, he had 10 special needs students. 

“That’s a big change in how we teach kids,” he said.

Kenck is part of the union’s bargaining team, which has been negotiating with the district since March. 

8 Photos
Cecilia Magistrale, in gray, joins her mom, Silver Star Elementary School teacher Angela Magistrale, right, and other picketers Friday morning, Aug. 19, 2016 in Southeast Vancouver.
Evergreen teachers picket Photo Gallery

“The issues are out there. It’s 1½ weeks until school. We should have this done by now,” he said.

Bargaining points

The following bargaining points are listed on the union’s Facebook page:

n Counseling and other special services need to be better staffed so students are ready to learn. Current staffing does not allow counselors to support students one-on-one.

n More support for special needs students. Current staffing does not provide one-to-one help.

n Provide basic materials, curriculum and instructional time for the benefit of students and teachers.

n Create incentives to solve the substitute teacher shortage. Stop using librarians, music, physical education and arts teachers to cover substitute teacher shortages.

n Pay competitive salaries and benefits commensurate with the rest of the state’s 10 largest districts. Evergreen is the state’s fifth-largest district.

With more than 26,000 students, Evergreen is the largest school district in Southwest Washington. The union represents more than 1,830 teachers.

Teacher salaries

Evergreen teachers earned between $40,417 and $76,179 in total compensation during the 2015-2016 school year. Without additional district money added to their pay through bargaining, district teachers would earn between $41,144 and $77,549 during the 2016-2017 school year. That bump in pay is the result of a raise from the state.

Rising health insurance premiums are part of the salary package being discussed, Lutz said. The state provides $780 a month for health insurance for each full-time employee, but the Evergreen district doesn’t kick in any extra money for teachers’ health care premiums. Some districts do. 

When Kenck started teaching 35 years ago, he said, the state covered the health insurance premium for his entire family. Over the years, that amount has diminished. Now only his own health insurance premium is paid by the state. His wife has her own health insurance and his kids are adults, so he’s OK, he said. 

But he’s worried about his fellow teacher, C.J. Butenschoen. He and his wife, also a teacher, have a new baby, and she is staying home this year. He’s taken on coaching football and teaching drama after school in order to make extra money. He thinks those extra jobs will pay for about half of his additional health care costs for his wife and infant. At the minimum, he will have to pay an additional $600 per month for health insurance premiums.

“I’m definitely not going to sacrifice my baby’s health,” Butenschoen said.

The district’s letter

Evergreen Public Schools sent a letter from Superintendent John Deeder to parents Friday afternoon. It referred to teachers as “the backbone of the district.” It says the district pays, and will continue to pay, fair local market wages and benefits and offer good working conditions.

A chunk of the problem lies with the state, the letter notes. While the Legislature has been court-ordered to fully fund basic education, this has not happened. Instead, the state provides school districts only a portion of the funds needed to pay salary and benefits. Thus, every request above that basic allocation is funded from levy dollars derived from property taxes and voted on locally.  It is a balancing act to ensure teachers are fairly compensated without asking for higher taxes from our community, according to the letter.


 Previously: Evergreen Public Schools and the teachers union, Evergreen Education Association, failed to reach an agreement during several bargaining sessions, including sessions Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.

What’s new: A state-appointed mediator joined the session Thursday.

What’s next: Mediated bargaining sessions are planned for Aug. 22, 23, 25 and 26. At the Aug. 30 union membership meeting, teachers will either ratify a new contract or vote to strike. The first day of school is Aug. 31. The current contract expires Aug. 31.

“The district has already offered a total compensation package to EEA members that exceeds what other school districts in Clark and Cowlitz counties offer their teachers, and is competitive (when the local cost-of-living is factored in) with our peer districts across the state,” Deeder wrote.

Deeder’s letter said the district and school board’s goal is to “come to a satisfactory resolution” with the union before school begins Aug. 31. But if that doesn’t happen, Deeder said, the options are for school to begin without a contract or the teachers would “vote for a work stoppage.”

The state requires 180 days of instruction per school year. If teachers vote to strike, Deeder said the school year will begin when the strike ends, and the end of the school year will be pushed later into June. 

Are strikes illegal?

State law addresses strikes by public employees, but not teachers specifically. Attorney General Rob McKenna wrote a formal opinion on the law in 2006: “In Washington, state and local public employees do not have a legally protected right to strike. No such right existed in common law, and none has been granted by statute. State statutes presently do not impose penalties on public employees for engaging in a strike. Under appropriate circumstances, a court may enjoin a public employee strike and may impose penalties for noncompliance.”

In short, public employees do not have a right to strike. However, the law does not establish any automatic penalties for striking. But a court can impose penalties on public employees. 

That’s what eventually happened after teachers in Kelso went on strike Sept. 16. A Cowlitz County judge ruled the strike illegal and ordered the teachers back to work. As the strike continued into its second week, the judge imposed a $2,000 per day fine on the union if teachers didn’t return to work. At that point, the union and the district reached an agreement on Sept. 27. 

Teachers in three other districts went on strike last fall: Seattle, South Whidbey Island and Pasco. 

In May 1973, stalled contract negotiations between Evergreen and the 300-member Evergreen Education Association became so heated that Clark County Superior Court Judge J. Guthrie Langsdorf sent three union leaders to the Clark County Jail for 43 to 45 days.

Columbian Education Reporter

Support local journalism

Your tax-deductible donation to The Columbian’s Community Funded Journalism program will contribute to better local reporting on key issues, including homelessness, housing, transportation and the environment. Reporters will focus on narrative, investigative and data-driven storytelling.

Local journalism needs your help. It’s an essential part of a healthy community and a healthy democracy.

Community Funded Journalism logo