PHOENIX — The Supreme Court’s decision to order the reinstatement of the “Remain in Mexico” immigration policy is sparking criticism from advocacy groups, praise by former President Donald Trump and promises by the Biden administration to appeal the policy, which forced people to wait in Mexico while seeking asylum in the U.S.
The decision, which came late Tuesday, said the Biden administration likely violated federal law by trying to end the Trump-era program, known as the Migrant Protection Protocols. The ruling raised many questions, ranging from whether a legal challenge would prevail to the practical effects of reinstatement if it stands.
WHAT’S NEXT FOR THE BIDEN ADMINISTRATION?
The Department of Homeland Security said it was taking steps to comply with the high court’s decision while the Biden administration appeals.
The administration could try again to end the program by having the department provide a fuller explanation for its decision to end Migrant Protection Protocols. White House spokeswoman Jen Psaki said Wednesday the administration would “vigorously challenge” the decision.
Trump, meanwhile, welcomed the court order and said the Biden government must now reinstate “one of my most successful and important programs in securing the border.”
During Trump’s presidency, the policy required tens of thousands of migrants seeking asylum in the U.S. to turn back to Mexico. It was meant to discourage asylum seekers, but critics said it denied people the legal right to seek protection in the U.S. and forced them to wait in dangerous Mexican border cities.
U.S. immigration experts note that no matter what happens over the long term, the Biden administration has wide discretion on how much it would reimplement the policy if appeals are unsuccessful.
“It could reimplement it on a very small scale for families who meet certain criteria from very specific nationalities, or it could do something broader,” said Jessica Bolter, associate policy analyst at the Migration Policy Institute in Washington.
HOW IS MEXICO REACTING?
Shortly after the order was issued Tuesday, Roberto Velasco, the Mexican government’s director for North America, tweeted that any decision his country makes on the ruling will be based on sovereignty and human rights.
During the Trump administration, the Mexican government said it was cooperating with the program for humanitarian reasons. Although migrants were granted humanitarian visas to stay in Mexico until they had their U.S. hearings, they often had to wait in dangerous areas controlled by cartels, leaving them vulnerable to being kidnapped, assaulted, raped or even killed. Others were transported by bus to parts of southern Mexico or “invited” to return to their home countries.
Mexico technically could block the program by refusing to accept migrants asked to stay in Mexico under the Migrant Protection Protocols, or MPP. But analysts like Tonatiuh Guillén, former head of Mexico’s migration agency, consider that unlikely given the country’s history of cooperation with the U.S.
Guillén said Mexican officials will probably go along even though the country doesn’t have sufficient resources to deal with an influx of asylum seekers at the border and nonprofit shelters south of the border are overwhelmed.
Still, more than 70 Mexican, U.S. and international NGOs have sent a letter asking President Andrés Manuel López Obrador not to accept the U.S. court decision.
“I don’t think either Mexico or the Biden administration want to reimplement MPP at its maximum capacity right now,” said Bolter. “If it is reimplemented at a low level, it will have serious consequences for the families or other migrants who are subjected to it. But overall, I think it’s unlikely to drastically change the policy landscape at the border.”
HOW ROBUST WAS THE PROGRAM IN RECENT YEARS?
Immigration specialists note that Migrant Protection Protocols already had been significantly scaled back during the pandemic as officials began using public health protocols to swiftly expel migrants.
The Trump administration placed roughly 6,000 migrants into the program from April 2020 to January 2021 — a fraction of the more than 71,000 migrants placed into the program overall, said Bolter. It launched the program in January 2019.
“Clearly, it wasn’t operating at the level it had been operating before, but there definitely were still people being placed into it,” said Bolter. She added that the program was largely being used for migrants who Mexico refused to take back under pandemic-era health protocols known as Title 42.
Victoria Neilson, managing attorney with CLINIC’s defending vulnerable populations program, noted that since the pandemic far fewer migrants have been placed in the MPP program, with many expelled from the border under the health protocols initiated under the Trump administration and continued by President Joe Biden.
WHAT ABOUT TITLE 42 EXPULSIONS?
The State Department is holding talks with the Mexican government as the administration reviews the Trump-era protocols to determine how they can be implemented while Title 42 is in effect, said a Homeland Security official who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss internal deliberations.
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention renewed the Title 42 public health powers early this month. The administration has emphasized that Title 42 is not an immigration authority, but a public health authority, and its continued use is dictated by the CDC’s analysis of the public health situation.
While Title 42 expulsions continue, the U.S. for now has suspended the processing into the U.S. of people who were returned to Mexico under Migrant Protection Protocols during the Trump administration.
In recent weeks, Central American migrants expelled under Title 42 have been flown by the U.S. into Mexico’s south, sparking concerns by U.N. agencies about vulnerable migrants who they say need humanitarian protection.
The U.S. government has intermittently flown Mexicans deep into Mexico for years to discourage repeat attempts, but flights that began this month from Brownsville, Texas, to the Mexican state capitals of Villahermosa and Tapachula, near the Guatemalan border, appear to be the first time that Central Americans have been flown deep into Mexico.
