Thursday,  February 13 , 2025

Linkedin Pinterest
Opinion
The following is presented as part of The Columbian’s Opinion content, which offers a point of view in order to provoke thought and debate of civic issues. Opinions represent the viewpoint of the author. Unsigned editorials represent the consensus opinion of The Columbian’s editorial board, which operates independently of the news department.
News / Opinion / Columns

Henneberger: Linking air crash to DEI is just prejudice talking

By Melinda Henneberger
Published: February 4, 2025, 6:01am

After watching Donald Trump try to pin Wednesday’s awful air collision over the Potomac on the diversity of our air traffic controllers, I am going to retire the word “unbelievable” from my vocabulary.

We do not know what caused this national tragedy and Trump said that. But he also suggested that 67 people lost their lives because Joe Biden lowered the standards for air traffic controllers, though there is not even a wisp of evidence behind that claim.

“It just could have been” caused by too much diversity in the ranks, he said. Or not.

We now know that air traffic control received no response from a military Black Hawk helicopter seconds before it collided with the American Airlines flight from Wichita to Washington, D.C.

But Trump didn’t wait to hear that. Instead, he put the air in air safety, carelessly summoning, based on nothing but his own prejudice, the idea that the FAA’s supposed roster of people with “severe intellectual and psychiatric disabilities” were to blame.

One reporter asked the president how, in the absence of any facts about what caused the crash, he could possibly know that. How could he both blame DEI for what happened and also say, “We don’t know that it was the controllers’ fault”?

Because unlike so many others, he answered, “I have common sense.”

Air traffic control is the ultimate merit-based job, and those who work under intense, insane, increasing pressure at Reagan National are already the best of the best. A preliminary report said that one air traffic controller was doing the job of two people when the crash happened, as allowed under FAA rules. But that has nothing to do with DEI.

If anything, this crash is a heartbreaking reminder of the importance of government workers like air traffic controllers and of regulation itself.

Stay informed on what is happening in Clark County, WA and beyond for only
$99/year

How were these wild statements from our president in a time of mourning supposed to comfort the grieving? They seemed designed to prickle, perturb and place an extra burden on the air traffic controllers who had to get right back to work on Thursday.

The hiring policies Trump was talking about have actually been in place since 2013, and when a reporter asked him why, if they let such slouches in the door, he hadn’t done anything about them during his first term, Trump disputed that and later said the reporter had asked “totally irrelevant and not very good questions.”

Former transportation secretary Pete Buttigieg rightly called Trump’s remarks “despicable.”

“As families grieve,” he said, “Trump should be leading, not lying.” The Biden administration “put safety first, drove down close calls, grew Air Traffic Control and had zero commercial airline crash fatalities out of millions of flights on our watch.”

Since taking office, Trump has started pushing out those federal workers who lack the brilliance to agree with him no matter what.

Last week, he fired the head of the Transportation Security Administration — someone he himself had originally appointed, now apparently sullied by the fact that Biden kept him on. And he got rid of the aviation security advisory group mandated by Congress after the 1988 PanAm 103 bombing over Lockerbie, Scotland. Or rather, the group still exists, but as of this week has no members: More genius.

Undermine air safety, food safety and environmental regulations, as Trump’s actions intend to do, or undercut the Federal Emergency Management Agency, which the president has talked about doing away with entirely, and people will die.

Whatever caused this crash, the spotlight on operations at Reagan National is also a reminder of the importance of expertise. And when Trump says we’re only going to be hiring Mensa air traffic controllers, how does that line up with his catastrophically unqualified picks for extremely important jobs?

There are many areas, air safety being only one, in which we really cannot slash, bully or bluster our way to a better America. If Trump himself is as smart as he constantly says he is, he will stop trying.


Melinda Henneberger is a columnist for the Kansas City Star.

Loading...