Just like HBO’s “Girls,” Comedy Central’s “Broad City” is a series about young women living in New York City, fumbling toward adulthood whether they like it or not. But while the two series share a central premise, their approaches to love, life and friendship couldn’t be more different. With the conclusion last week of each show’s most recent season, these differences have become more apparent.
Consider the episode of “Broad City,”which completed its third season, when longtime best friends Abbi Abrams (Abbi Jacobson) and Ilana Wexler (Ilana Glazer) put their apartments on Airbnb in an attempt to make a quick buck over the weekend. Temporarily homeless, the pair attempt to camp out on the roof of Ilana’s building, until a stiff breeze demolishes their tent. Undaunted, the girls decide to club hop in lieu of couch crashing, and their adventures together continue.
Meanwhile, in the fifth season of “Girls,” Hannah Horvath (Lena Dunham) had a harder time of it. After realizing her former best friend, Jessa, is now dating her ex-boyfriend, Adam, and breaking up with her current beau, Fran, Hannah finds herself without her established support system to lean on. She’s lost Jessa to love, Marnie to marriage and Shoshanna to Japan. Eventually she ends up reconnecting with a former nemesis and spends the day in a state of true friendship she hasn’t experienced with her actual friends in ages.
When “Girls,” created by Dunham, debuted in 2012, it was critically lauded for its raw and refreshing tale about four 20-something friends struggling to find their own way in the world as they flub their careers, relationships and lives.