Justice — and punishment in the name of that justice — should not be viewed as an opportunity for profit. The notion of fairness and the consideration of civil rights must be dealt with on a higher plane than the simple balancing of dollars and cents.
Because of that, the Obama administration’s announcement that it will work to phase out the use of private prisons as part of the federal corrections system is long overdue. And while the move will, in truth, impact a small percentage of prisoners and have a minimal effect on how Americans enact their notion of crime and punishment, it is important in raising the level of discourse surrounding the issue.
Last week, U.S. Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates announced a change in direction for the federal prison system by issuing a directive for officials to either decline to renew contracts for private prisons or scale them back when they come up for renewal. In support of the move, Yates cited a declining federal prison population and a report from the Justice Department’s Office of the Inspector General, which found that private prisons are less efficient and more dangerous than government-run facilities.
Overall, phasing out private prisons will have more of a symbolic impact than a practical one. A total of 13 private prisons house about 22,000 federal inmates — roughly 12 percent of the Bureau of Prisons inmate population. Furthermore, the directive does not include state prisons, which house a much larger percentage of the nation’s roughly 1.5 million prisoners; nor does it include privately run detention centers under the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency or the U.S. Marshals Service. One of the largest privately run immigration facilities is a 1,575-bed detention center near Tacoma that is run by the GEO Group.