“A Quiet Passion” is Terence Davies’ eighth feature, and the 71-year-old English native has made a stern, evocative feature on the life and poetry of Emily Dickinson, portrayed by Cynthia Nixon. Most historical biographies on film behave as tidy museum pieces, however lifelessly, while others strive for modernity at the expense of plausibility. Co-starring Jennifer Ehle and Keith Carradine, “A Quiet Passion” avoids both suggestions and the result is the latest Davies gem.
In Dickinson, writer-director Davies may have found a kind of soul mate: Just as Dickinson fought with her family, her editors and her entire world about her rightful place within that world, Davies considers himself a fortunate independent filmmaker, if a fundamentally puzzled one.
He has never made a film set in the present day, and Davies says he never will. “The problem is, I’m a technophobe. I can’t work any of this technology.” (He refers to iPhones and their various relations.) “I don’t understand the modern world. I simply don’t understand it. I’m also repelled by it. I’m repelled by the narcissism of everything. Why do you need to take a photograph of yourself when you’re out for dinner? I do think that is really dangerous. None of us are central to the universe. I just don’t understand the modern world. There’s something … dead about it. What to do with all this information? What is it for? How can you watch the news with subtitles running along the bottom of the screen?”
Nixon, currently on Broadway in a revival of “The Little Foxes,” agreed to play Dickinson for Davies nearly five years ago. She stuck with the project long enough for Davies to secure funding. He has nothing but praise for the actress, as well as for Ehle, who plays Emily’s sister, Vinnie. “Gorgeous” is his one-word review for Ehle; “lovely,” the word he chooses for Carradine.