Leubsdorf: Debt ceiling showdown again

One problem with the Republican effort is that failure to increase the debt ceiling won’t affect the spending that caused it. And with control of just the House, the GOP probably lacks the votes to achieve significant future cuts. But it could cause the government to default on its financial obligations and, in a worst-case scenario, create a global recession.

There is also some hypocrisy in Republicans presenting themselves as the champions of fiscal responsibility. Their large tax cuts and defense increases make them as complicit in the underlying deficit problem as the Democrats are for passing large domestic social programs.

Until World War I, there was no such thing as a debt ceiling, and Congress voted each time the government wanted to issue bonds to finance a specific undertaking. But in the Second Liberty Bond Act of 1917, Congress ceded that authority to the Treasury but set an overall limit of $15 billion, the equivalent of $347 billion today.

Over the last 30 years, deficit spending has grown faster under both parties. And increasing partisanship made the periodic debt ceiling fights more acrimonious. On at least three prior occasions, all during Democratic administrations, GOP congressional majorities sought and failed to achieve significant federal spending curbs by leveraging debt ceiling increases.

In 1995, after Republicans won the House for the first time in 40 years, an impasse over the debt ceiling and federal domestic spending between President Bill Clinton and House Speaker Newt Gingrich led to federal government shutdowns of five and 21 days.

In 1999, a Republican Congress and Clinton balanced the budget for the first time in 30 years. But the surplus quickly vanished, as the Bush administration cut taxes, undertook two overseas wars and added drug coverage to Medicare without paying for them.

In 2011, a serious impasse developed after the Obama administration resisted House GOP demands for large spending cuts after election of a more conservative majority fueled by the tea party movement. Global stock markets plunged before President Barack Obama and Speaker John Boehner reached a complex budget agreement with slightly more spending cuts than increases in the national debt.

But in 2013, House Republicans again refused to raise the debt ceiling, this time unless Obama defunded his signature achievement, the Affordable Care Act. After a partial government shutdown, the GOP yielded.

Each time, House Republicans refused initially to increase the debt ceiling without spending curbs. Each time, they yielded, but only after creating unnecessary financial havoc, gaining minimal cuts and losing politically. All the disputes were settled before causing the ultimate disaster: a government default.

The latest impasse became inevitable in November when Republicans won narrow House control and vowed to oppose the next debt ceiling increase without significant spending cuts.

With Democrats holding both the Senate and the White House, they are fighting an uphill battle, both tactically and politically. Their principal recourse — shutting down the government — proved unpopular in the past. And causing a government financial default could prove even more disastrous.

Without compromise, economic disaster will loom. It’s hardly what Congress had in mind back in 1917.